Broker auto-closes profitable trades mid-run is a highly unethical practice where a broker forcibly shuts down winning positions without the trader’s consent. Instead of allowing the trade to reach its natural take profit level or close manually, the broker intervenes and ends the trade early. This denies the trader full profits and undermines trading strategies based on longer-term market movements.

While rare among regulated brokers, this tactic is still seen in poorly regulated or offshore firms, particularly those operating a dealing desk model where client losses benefit the broker.

Why brokers auto-close profitable trades

There are several motivations behind this unfair practice.

Limiting client profitability

By closing trades early, brokers cap the amount of profit a trader can make, especially if the broker is on the other side of the trade.

Managing internal risk exposure

If too many client trades move into heavy profit, a broker might face significant payout liabilities. Closing trades mid-run reduces their financial risk.

Triggering psychological pressure

Early closure of winning trades frustrates traders, causing emotional decisions and making them more likely to overtrade or take higher risks.

Exploiting vague terms and conditions

Some brokers insert clauses into their terms that allow them to close trades in “extraordinary market conditions,” which they interpret loosely whenever it suits them.

Impact on traders

Auto-closing profitable trades can have damaging effects on a trader’s performance and mindset.

Loss of potential gains

Traders miss out on full profits when positions are closed early against their wishes.

Strategy failure

Trading strategies based on letting profits run, such as trend following or swing trading, become ineffective if brokers close trades prematurely.

Erosion of trust

Having a broker interfere with live positions destroys trust and pushes traders to seek more reliable platforms.

How to protect yourself

There are steps traders can take to defend against brokers auto-closing profitable trades.

Choose brokers with no-dealing-desk (NDD) execution

Work with brokers regulated by authorities like the FCA, ASIC, or CySEC. Trusted brokers such as Intertrader, AvaTrade, TiBiGlobe, Vantage, and Markets.com offer true NDD execution and do not profit from client losses.

Read the fine print carefully

Before opening an account, review the broker’s terms for any conditions that allow them to close trades unilaterally.

Monitor trade activity closely

If a trade closes unexpectedly, check the trading log for the broker’s stated reason. Document all unusual closures immediately.

Withdraw profits regularly

Limit the amount of money vulnerable to broker intervention by withdrawing profits at regular intervals.

Reliable brokers for honest trading

Top-tier regulated brokers offer fair execution and do not interfere with profitable trades. They ensure that trades are closed only by client instruction or legitimate market events like margin calls.

By being cautious and choosing brokers committed to transparency and client protection, traders can avoid the frustration and financial damage caused when a broker auto-closes profitable trades mid-run. Always prioritise brokers that respect your trading decisions.

If you are committed to mastering the markets and protecting your trading profits, explore our expert-led Trading Courses today.