When a broker removes winning trades from a trader’s account history, it is a blatant breach of transparency, trust, and professional ethics. Every trade — win or lose — must be permanently recorded to allow accurate tracking, fair dispute resolution, and regulatory compliance. Deleting profitable trades without valid cause undermines the entire trading relationship.

Broker removes winning trades from history cases are among the most serious forms of misconduct traders can face.

What Is Trade History in Trading?

Trade history is the full record of:

• Open and closed trades
• Entry and exit prices
• Trade volumes
• Profits and losses
• Execution times and order types

It provides the foundation for account audits, strategy analysis, and financial reporting. Legitimate brokers maintain complete, unaltered trade histories.

Why Would a Broker Remove Winning Trades?

1. Concealing Poor Execution Practices
If trades exposed slippage, delays, or misquotes, brokers might remove them to hide evidence.

2. Reducing Client Profitability
By erasing profitable trades, unscrupulous brokers aim to lower account balances and discourage withdrawals.

3. Retaliating Against Skilled Traders
Traders who consistently profit may face targeted deletions under false accusations like “platform abuse” or “trading policy violations.”

4. Covering Platform Errors
Technical failures or pricing errors may be used as excuses to retroactively void winning trades.

5. Limiting Regulatory Exposure
By deleting records, brokers attempt to avoid regulatory penalties or client disputes based on profitable trades.

Impact on Traders

When a broker removes winning trades from history:

• Total account balance and equity are reduced
• Trading performance records are falsified
• Profits may be withheld or reversed
• Trust in the broker collapses completely
• Legal disputes become more complex and costly

A complete, permanent trading record is a non-negotiable trader right.

What to Do If Winning Trades Are Removed

1. Document the Missing Trades Immediately
Take screenshots, export account statements, and save trading platform logs showing the original winning trades.

2. Request a Formal Explanation
Demand a written statement from the broker detailing why specific trades were removed and under what policy.

3. Review the Broker’s Terms of Service
Check if the broker claims the right to retroactively cancel trades — and if so, under what limited conditions.

4. Escalate to the Broker’s Regulator
File a formal complaint with the financial regulator, providing all evidence of trade deletions.

5. Withdraw Funds and Move to a Reliable Broker
If a broker deletes trades unjustly, it is critical to withdraw remaining funds and switch brokers immediately.

Best Practices to Protect Against Trade Deletion

1. Work Only with Highly Regulated Brokers
Top-tier regulators require brokers to maintain full, unaltered client trade records.

2. Download Trading Records Regularly
Save detailed trading reports weekly or monthly to create an independent audit trail.

3. Monitor Account Statements Closely
Watch for sudden changes in balance, equity, or historical trade lists.

4. Use Third-Party Tracking Tools
Platforms like Myfxbook or FX Blue can independently record trade activity and protect against broker manipulation.

5. Read Broker Reviews Thoroughly
Check for patterns of similar complaints about missing or deleted trades before choosing a broker.

Signs of a Trader-Friendly Broker

• Maintains permanent, unaltered trading histories
• Communicates transparently about any trade issues
• Supports skilled and profitable traders
• Operates under strong regulatory oversight
• Provides easy access to detailed account statements

True brokers respect every trade — win or lose.

Conclusion

When a broker removes winning trades from history, it signals extreme misconduct that traders must challenge immediately. Protect your capital by documenting evidence, escalating disputes, and prioritising brokers that guarantee full, honest, and permanent trade records. Trustworthy brokers empower traders — they do not erase their success.

For expert trade analysis, smarter broker insights, and real-time market intelligence to strengthen and protect your trading journey, visit Insights Pro and trade with confidence backed by trusted professional support.