Market volatility is a natural part of the financial landscape, but the belief that all markets crash in September is more myth than fact. While historical data does highlight a recurring dip in equities during this month, it’s essential to explore whether this pattern holds universal truth or is simply a statistical anomaly. Understanding the origins of the “September Effect” can help investors stay grounded and make informed decisions during what some fear as a notoriously turbulent time.

The historical origins of the September Effect

The term “September Effect” emerged from historical trends in the US stock market, particularly the S&P 500, which has posted negative average returns more frequently in September than any other month since 1928. Although not every year follows this trend, the average performance does lean negative over the long term.

Several key events reinforce this sentiment. The 2008 financial crisis intensified in September. Similarly, the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 had significant economic repercussions. These examples have fuelled the narrative that September is a “cursed” month for markets, even though such events are exceptions rather than rules.

Is this pattern global?

While the US markets provide the most cited evidence, the “September Effect” isn’t universal. Other major indices, like the FTSE 100, DAX, or Nikkei, don’t show a consistent September weakness. Emerging markets also don’t reflect this pattern regularly. This suggests the effect may be more tied to regional investor behaviour, particularly in the United States, than to a global economic cycle.

Possible reasons behind September volatility

1. Institutional portfolio rebalancing
Fund managers often return from summer holidays in early September, reassessing portfolios ahead of the year-end. This shift in strategy can lead to sell-offs in underperforming sectors, which contributes to broader market declines.

2. Tax-loss harvesting
In some jurisdictions, September marks the beginning of tax-loss harvesting, where investors sell losing positions to offset gains. While more common in December, some US investors act earlier to prepare.

3. Seasonal pessimism
Investor sentiment tends to be more cautious during September. With the holiday season approaching and third-quarter earnings season looming, many traders tighten positions, adding to overall risk aversion.

4. Historical self-fulfilment
Much of the “September crash” idea is self-reinforcing. As more market participants believe in the phenomenon, their actions — such as early selling or risk-off trades — contribute to making it true, at least in part.

Debunking the myth: not every September leads to losses

Despite the statistical average, many Septembers have delivered positive returns for stock markets. For example, the S&P 500 rose in September 2010, 2012, and 2018. Context matters. Economic conditions, monetary policy, and investor sentiment all play a larger role than the month itself.

In fact, some years see markets rally in September due to strong earnings or dovish central bank decisions. Thus, relying solely on seasonal patterns to predict crashes can be misleading and dangerous.

How investors should respond

Rather than fearing September, investors should treat it like any other month — with due diligence and a focus on fundamentals. Avoid emotional decision-making based on calendar myths. If anything, September could present opportunities to buy quality assets at lower prices during brief pullbacks.

Practical strategies include:

• Maintaining a diversified portfolio to reduce exposure to single-market risks.
• Using stop-losses and hedging tools where appropriate.
• Keeping a long-term perspective rather than reacting to short-term volatility.

Conclusion: Is the September crash inevitable?

No — markets do not always crash in September. While historical averages show a tendency for weakness, the effect is neither consistent nor guaranteed. Market dynamics are shaped by a complex mix of economic data, investor behaviour, central bank policies, and global events — not just the calendar. Smart investors use September as a reminder to stay informed, disciplined, and focused on long-term goals.

Explore more insights into market psychology and seasonal strategies in our expert-led Trading Courses.