It’s tempting to skip over profitable trades when reviewing your trading journal. After all, if the trade made money, it must have been a success — right? Not necessarily. The belief that only losing trades require analysis overlooks a critical truth in trading: a profitable trade is not always a good trade, and a losing trade is not always a bad one.

Why traders often ignore winning trades

1. Outcome bias
Traders tend to equate profits with good decisions. This mindset assumes that because a trade was profitable, the process behind it must have been sound — even if luck played a role.

2. Overconfidence
Success can breed complacency. After a few winning trades, traders may feel invincible, reducing their willingness to scrutinise what actually happened. This can lead to a string of undisciplined trades masked by short-term gains.

3. Time prioritisation
When journaling or reviewing trades, it’s common to prioritise problem-solving. Losses feel more urgent, so they get the attention — while profitable trades are archived and forgotten.

Why reviewing profitable trades is essential

1. Validate your process
A winning trade could have broken every rule in your plan and still resulted in profit. By reviewing it, you can separate good luck from good trading. Did you follow your setup criteria? Was your risk-reward acceptable? Was the timing justified?

2. Reinforce best practices
Reviewing successful trades that followed your strategy reinforces good habits. It builds confidence not just in the outcome, but in the process — which is critical for long-term consistency.

3. Identify premature exits
A trade may have been profitable, but could you have let it run longer? Did fear cause you to take profits too early? Reviewing winning trades helps you fine-tune your exits and unlock better returns in future setups.

4. Uncover hidden weaknesses
Some profitable trades expose underlying flaws — like entering too late, sizing too aggressively, or trading impulsively. These may not hurt you now, but over time, they can lead to larger drawdowns.

5. Build a model of your edge
Analysing your best trades helps you understand your edge more clearly. What conditions, signals, or setups consistently deliver results? This insight helps you scale what’s working and filter out distractions.

How to review profitable trades effectively

• Did I follow my plan? If not, the profit may be misleading.
• What went right? Look for repeatable strengths — entry timing, patience, clarity.
• Was my mindset clear? Note whether you felt in control or emotionally reactive.
• Could I have managed it better? Review your stop, take-profit, and trailing decisions.
• What is the key takeaway? Write one sentence on what made this trade work.

Conclusion: Should you review profitable trades?

Yes — absolutely. Ignoring profitable trades means missing out on valuable insights that could sharpen your strategy and reinforce discipline. In trading, the quality of your process matters more than the short-term result. By reviewing both wins and losses, you build a feedback loop that leads to smarter decisions, fewer mistakes, and stronger long-term performance.

Develop the habits of elite traders with our hands-on Trading Courses that teach you how to master both the process and the mindset behind profitable performance.